Yesterday's Airlines
  • Home
  • About
  • My Fleets
    • My Hobby Room >
      • The Old Hobby Room
    • US Trunk Fleets >
      • My American Airlines Fleet
      • My Braniff Intnl Fleet
      • My Continental Fleet
      • My Delta Air Lines Fleet
      • My Eastern Air Lines Fleet
      • My National Airlines Fleet
      • My Northeast / Capital Fleet
      • My Northwest Airlines Fleet
      • My Pan Am Fleet
      • My TWA Fleet
      • My United Airlines Fleet
      • My Western Airlines Fleet
    • US Local Service Fleets >
      • My Frontier Airlines Fleet
      • My Hughes Airwest Fleet
      • My Ozark Airlines Fleet
      • My Republic Airlines Fleet
      • My Texas Int Fleet
    • US Other Fleets >
      • My Alaska Airlines Fleet
      • My Hawaiian / Aloha Fleet
      • My PSA Fleet
      • My Flying Tigers Fleet
      • My World Airways Fleet
    • UK Fleets >
      • My British Airways Fleet
    • Canadian Fleets
    • China Fleets >
      • My Cathay Pacific Fleet
    • Russian Fleet >
      • Russian Fleet Video
    • Fleet Videos >
      • US Trunk Airlines
    • Aviation Stickers >
      • ATR Stickers
      • A300 Stickers
      • DC-9 Stickers
      • DC-10 Stickers
  • Aviation Blogs
    • Airline History Blog
    • Model Blog
  • Airline Dev
    • CANADA >
      • Canadian Mainline
      • Canadian Charters & LCCs
      • Canadian Regionals
    • CHINA >
      • The Big Three
      • Hainan Airlines Group
      • Other Chinese Airlines
    • MEXICO >
      • 1988-2005: Competition arrives
      • 2005-2014: Low cost in Mexico
      • Mexican Airline Genealogy
      • Mexicana Livery Tails
    • RUSSIA >
      • Aeroflot Group
      • S7 Airlines & AiRUnion
      • Other Russian Airlines
    • SOUTH AFRICA
    • UNITED KINGDOM >
      • BA Genealogy Pt1
      • BA Genealogy Pt2
      • BA Genealogy Pt3
      • BUIA & BUAF Genealogies
      • UK Charter Airlines Pt1
      • UK Charter Airlines Pt2
      • BEA Liveries 1946-1974
      • BOAC Liveries 1939-1974
      • BA Liveries 1974-2015
    • UNITED STATES >
      • Trunk & Local Service Airlines >
        • American / TWA Genealogy
        • Delta / Northwest Genealogy
        • United / Continental Genealogy
        • Braniff / Eastern / US Airways Genealogy
      • Territorial Airlines
      • Intra-State Airlines
      • Supplemental Airlines
      • Deregulation Startups 1
      • Deregulation Startups 2
      • Trunk Airline Livery Changes 1959-1980
  • Airports
    • Dowse National Airport >
      • Gallery 1: Chicago c.1966
      • Gallery 2: Miami c.1970
    • Wright Field Municipal >
      • Wright Field Video Tour
    • Xin Long International
    • Imogenia Intnl 1/600 Scale
    • Real Airport Histories >
      • Albany International
      • Dallas Love Field
      • Rochester International Pt1
      • Rochester International Pt2
      • San Francisco - 1927-1959
      • San Francisco - 1959-1978
      • San Francisco - 1978-2015
      • San Jose International
      • San Jose International Pt2
  • Mould Reviews
    • Airbus >
      • Airbus A300
      • Airbus A310
      • Airbus A320
      • Airbus A330-200/300
      • Airbus A330-200F
      • Airbus A330 Beluga XL
    • Boeing >
      • Boeing B-377 Stratocruiser
      • Boeing 707-120/138/720
      • Boeing 707-320/420
      • Boeing 727-100
      • Boeing 727-200
      • Boeing 737-100/200
      • Boeing 737-300/400/500
      • Boeing 737NG
      • Boeing 747-100/200
      • Boeing 747SP
      • Boeing 757-200
      • Boeing 767-200
      • Boeing 767-300
      • Boeing 777-200
    • British >
      • BAC One-Eleven 200-500
      • BAE-146 / Avro RJ-85-100
      • De Havilland DH-106 Comet
      • Hawker Siddeley Trident
      • Shorts 360
      • Vickers VC10
      • Vickers Viscount
    • Douglas >
      • Douglas DC-3 / C-47
      • Douglas DC-6
      • Douglas DC-7
      • Douglas DC-7C
      • Douglas DC-8-10-50
      • Douglas DC-8-60s/70s
      • Douglas DC-9-10
      • Douglas DC-9
      • McDonnell Douglas DC-10
      • McDonnell Douglas MD-11
      • McDonnell Douglas MD-80
      • McDonnell Douglas MD-90
    • Lockheed >
      • Lockheed Constellation
      • Lockheed Super Connie
      • Lockheed L-1649 Starliner
      • Lockheed L-188 Electra
      • Lockheed L-1011 Tristar 1
      • Lockheed L-1011 Tristar 500
    • Other >
      • Convair CV-240-580
      • Convair CV-880/990
      • Curtiss C-46
      • Fairchild F-27 / Fokker F27
      • Fairchild-Hiller FH-227
      • SE 210 Caravelle
    • Russian >
      • Ilyushin IL-62
      • Ilyushin IL-86/IL-96
      • Tupolev TU-154B-2/M
  • Real As It Gets
    • Real As It Gets - 1/200
    • Real As It Gets - Africa
    • Real As It Gets - Asia
    • Real As It Gets - China
    • Real As It Gets - Europe
    • Real As It Gets - Middle East
    • Real As It Gets - N America
    • Real As It Gets - Oceania
    • Real As It Gets - Russia
    • Real As It Gets - S America
  • Links
1:400 Model News & Airport Model Blog

Aeroclassics New GSE Sets Pt2: The Modern

23/9/2017

2 Comments

 
Picture
When in August Aeroclassics announced new modern GSE sets for a pair of Chinese A330s I was excited. I have a large Chinese airport model, plus really like the classic GSE sets Aeroclassics produce so surely these would be awesome additions to my collection? Sadly it is not to be. To say I'm disappointed in these sets is an understatement. Let's take a look at why.
For a far more complimentary review of Aeroclassics classic GSE sets see part 1:
  • Aeroclassics New GSE Sets Pt1: The Classics

Picture
The Air China set. From distance they look ok.
I guess my first warning should have been when these sets were delayed by a few months. I wonder if there were issues in the design and creation of them that led to the delays? Judging by the final product they should have delayed them longer until they got it right!
Picture
First let me say that the Airbus A330s these GSE sets come with are awesome models. No problems there - the Aeroclassics A330 is great. Also let me say that not all the models come with the GSE, you had to select to pay extra for them, and they weren't cheap - I'm talking approaching USD$50, which is substantially more than the classic sets were. Maybe my hopes were set too high having seen what others have done with recent GSE?
GSE Components
Perhaps I was just fantasising but when the new sets were announced I was under the impression that they were going to be all new sets, especially as most of the old AC GSE is clearly classic in nature. This is not the case and of the 12 pieces (yes there are 3 less pieces than in the classic sets) 7 of them are the same as in the classic sets. Below are the 7 retro items in the sets (note the broken baggage cart):
Picture
Now if these were Chinese airliners from the 1990s that would make sense as back then China was rather old-fashioned and there was still lots of old equipment floating about. Nowadays these pieces hardly fit a modern Chinese airport. This mostly applies to the tanker truck and the food truck, and to a lesser extent the sanitation truck too. Don't get me wrong I love these old pieces in the classic sets, but not here.
This brings me to the next peculiarity - the choice of GSE elements. One of the new GSE pieces is a tug of the type that connects directly to the aircraft landing gear. So why is a standard tug bar included in the set also? There is nothing it can connect to. Plus they include two baggage carts but again there is nothing in the set that can pull them, even though there are three vehicles in the old set that could do this all of which would be fine. So of the 12 pieces 3 are effectively useless.
New GSE Pieces
So there are 5 new GSE pieces in the set of 4 different designs. None are very impressive and the mobile airstairs in particular are a major step backwards.
Picture
Aeroclassics existing mobile airstairs. Solid, reliable and just in need of some extra detail printing
Picture
The new airstairs: featureless cab, lopsided stairs, not all wheels touch the ground
Aeroclassics had a perfectly good set of mobile airstairs already so why they needed replacing with this piece of shit is beyond me. It strongly resembles the old Dragon Wings airstairs but is no way near as well made. It doesn't sit on its wheelbase correctly and entertainingly the extendable stairs are made so badly that they cannot reach a widebody aircraft. The only way they can be made to do so is by pushing them up against the jet as away from it they droop badly, as you can see below:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Dragon airstairs on the left and the new AC ones on the right.
Picture
The new Aeroclassics bus on the left and the old Dragon Wings one on the right. Dragon's plastic allows for better detailing and precision
The new bus also bears a striking resemblance to the old Dragon Wings bus but unlike the Dragon parts it is completely metal. This makes it very heavy and poorly detailed. The printing is bland and weak and it looks poor even against the old Dragon bus let alone against the awesome buses being made by the likes of JC Wings. The lack of proper wheels and wheel cavities is another weakness. Once again Aeroclassics had an ok bus and this one is hardly an upgrade.
To the right is the existing Aeroclassics bus. It was too wide but did the job I thought. It was at least well shaped unlike the new bus, which has oddly curvy sides all over the place.
Picture
Picture
There is a little bus that has also been added but it is rather formless and pointless. In fact it's a little hard to tell the front from the back! At least it has separate wheels.
Picture
The same can't be said for the tow truck. This is another poorly shaped block of metal. The wheels are just painted on, and even then poorly, and there is little ground clearance. When used alongside the detailed 1:400 aircraft models they look very toylike.
Picture
Ten years ago these new GSE designs would have been just about acceptable, but nowadays with JC Wings and Panda Models (ironically they illegally made some great GSE under the Aeroclassics name) making very detailed GSE they just can't compete. Below are some examples of better quality GSE made over the past few years:
Picture
Modern tow tugs by Panda Models
Picture
Modern buses by Panda and JC Wings respectively
Picture
Probably the best GSE available. Fire engines by Panda Models
Quality
For some reason these two GSE sets are far and away the worst GSE sets I've ever got from Aeroclassics in terms of quality. I own about 20 sets and none have as many quality issues as these do, and most of mine are getting on in age too.
Out of the box two tyres were off their vehicles and one of the baggage carts had a static wheel broken off completely. One of the food trucks has a poorly connected door and one of the belt loader's belts is not properly connected so won't stay upright. The new mobile airstairs are very shoddily put together and don't sit on their wheels properly either. Across the board the paint is thick and the details light.
Livery
Picture
New livery A330, old livery GSE
Now the icing on the cake with the China Eastern set is that it is in the old livery, whilst the aircraft that goes with it is in the new livery. This just doesn't make sense and whilst I have plenty of old livery China Eastern aircraft that really isn't the point.
Summary
So overall these 'modern' GSE sets are poor. Poorly designed, poorly thought out and poorly constructed. They could have been improved by some simple things - like keeping the old mobile airstairs and replacing the tow bar with a baggage cart, but fundamentally none of the new components are very good. This is definitely a missed opportunity in my opinion.
It is not often that I have to say bad things about Aeroclassics but in this case I'd have preferred it if they'd have stuck with some of the older GSE elements. The four missing ones in my Iran Air set for example are pretty decent. They could have just added the new tug too (if they couldn't make it better) and somehow I think I'd have been a lot happier with the set.
Picture
2 Comments
Adrian Balch
23/9/2017 10:51:23 pm

Ah Richard, but there is strategy here - these are not for serious collectors like us, but clearly aimed at a new market - Chinese kiddies aged 6-10 who couldn't care less as long as they have play value!!! You said the models are available without the GSE, so those are for our market surely?

Reply
RStretton
24/9/2017 01:13:52 am

My understanding is that originally the models were only with the GSE but the price became an issue. I think Chinese collectors if anything are more discerning than Westerners judging by the conversations I've had with them. Considering the intense competition for Chinese airlines from AC, PHX, JC and Panda I'm surprised that this is AC's response.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    I'm Richard Stretton: a fan of 1/400 scale model aircraft and airports. This blog reports work on my model airport dioramas and discussion of the model manufacturers output.


    RSS Feed


    Archives

    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015

    Categories

    All
    Aeroclassics
    Airline Manufacture
    Airport Diorama Design
    Auckland Spotting
    Aviation400
    BigBird
    Book Review
    Detailed Mould Reviews
    Dowse National Airport
    Dream Air
    Gemini Jets
    GSE
    Hobby Room
    HYJLwings
    JC Wings
    Model Moulds
    Model Photography
    Model Vs Model
    My Collection
    New Releases
    NG Models
    Panda Models
    Phoenix
    Plane Spotting
    Real Airports
    Retailers
    Retro Models
    Wishlists
    Wright Field
    Xīn Lóng International

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • About
  • My Fleets
    • My Hobby Room >
      • The Old Hobby Room
    • US Trunk Fleets >
      • My American Airlines Fleet
      • My Braniff Intnl Fleet
      • My Continental Fleet
      • My Delta Air Lines Fleet
      • My Eastern Air Lines Fleet
      • My National Airlines Fleet
      • My Northeast / Capital Fleet
      • My Northwest Airlines Fleet
      • My Pan Am Fleet
      • My TWA Fleet
      • My United Airlines Fleet
      • My Western Airlines Fleet
    • US Local Service Fleets >
      • My Frontier Airlines Fleet
      • My Hughes Airwest Fleet
      • My Ozark Airlines Fleet
      • My Republic Airlines Fleet
      • My Texas Int Fleet
    • US Other Fleets >
      • My Alaska Airlines Fleet
      • My Hawaiian / Aloha Fleet
      • My PSA Fleet
      • My Flying Tigers Fleet
      • My World Airways Fleet
    • UK Fleets >
      • My British Airways Fleet
    • Canadian Fleets
    • China Fleets >
      • My Cathay Pacific Fleet
    • Russian Fleet >
      • Russian Fleet Video
    • Fleet Videos >
      • US Trunk Airlines
    • Aviation Stickers >
      • ATR Stickers
      • A300 Stickers
      • DC-9 Stickers
      • DC-10 Stickers
  • Aviation Blogs
    • Airline History Blog
    • Model Blog
  • Airline Dev
    • CANADA >
      • Canadian Mainline
      • Canadian Charters & LCCs
      • Canadian Regionals
    • CHINA >
      • The Big Three
      • Hainan Airlines Group
      • Other Chinese Airlines
    • MEXICO >
      • 1988-2005: Competition arrives
      • 2005-2014: Low cost in Mexico
      • Mexican Airline Genealogy
      • Mexicana Livery Tails
    • RUSSIA >
      • Aeroflot Group
      • S7 Airlines & AiRUnion
      • Other Russian Airlines
    • SOUTH AFRICA
    • UNITED KINGDOM >
      • BA Genealogy Pt1
      • BA Genealogy Pt2
      • BA Genealogy Pt3
      • BUIA & BUAF Genealogies
      • UK Charter Airlines Pt1
      • UK Charter Airlines Pt2
      • BEA Liveries 1946-1974
      • BOAC Liveries 1939-1974
      • BA Liveries 1974-2015
    • UNITED STATES >
      • Trunk & Local Service Airlines >
        • American / TWA Genealogy
        • Delta / Northwest Genealogy
        • United / Continental Genealogy
        • Braniff / Eastern / US Airways Genealogy
      • Territorial Airlines
      • Intra-State Airlines
      • Supplemental Airlines
      • Deregulation Startups 1
      • Deregulation Startups 2
      • Trunk Airline Livery Changes 1959-1980
  • Airports
    • Dowse National Airport >
      • Gallery 1: Chicago c.1966
      • Gallery 2: Miami c.1970
    • Wright Field Municipal >
      • Wright Field Video Tour
    • Xin Long International
    • Imogenia Intnl 1/600 Scale
    • Real Airport Histories >
      • Albany International
      • Dallas Love Field
      • Rochester International Pt1
      • Rochester International Pt2
      • San Francisco - 1927-1959
      • San Francisco - 1959-1978
      • San Francisco - 1978-2015
      • San Jose International
      • San Jose International Pt2
  • Mould Reviews
    • Airbus >
      • Airbus A300
      • Airbus A310
      • Airbus A320
      • Airbus A330-200/300
      • Airbus A330-200F
      • Airbus A330 Beluga XL
    • Boeing >
      • Boeing B-377 Stratocruiser
      • Boeing 707-120/138/720
      • Boeing 707-320/420
      • Boeing 727-100
      • Boeing 727-200
      • Boeing 737-100/200
      • Boeing 737-300/400/500
      • Boeing 737NG
      • Boeing 747-100/200
      • Boeing 747SP
      • Boeing 757-200
      • Boeing 767-200
      • Boeing 767-300
      • Boeing 777-200
    • British >
      • BAC One-Eleven 200-500
      • BAE-146 / Avro RJ-85-100
      • De Havilland DH-106 Comet
      • Hawker Siddeley Trident
      • Shorts 360
      • Vickers VC10
      • Vickers Viscount
    • Douglas >
      • Douglas DC-3 / C-47
      • Douglas DC-6
      • Douglas DC-7
      • Douglas DC-7C
      • Douglas DC-8-10-50
      • Douglas DC-8-60s/70s
      • Douglas DC-9-10
      • Douglas DC-9
      • McDonnell Douglas DC-10
      • McDonnell Douglas MD-11
      • McDonnell Douglas MD-80
      • McDonnell Douglas MD-90
    • Lockheed >
      • Lockheed Constellation
      • Lockheed Super Connie
      • Lockheed L-1649 Starliner
      • Lockheed L-188 Electra
      • Lockheed L-1011 Tristar 1
      • Lockheed L-1011 Tristar 500
    • Other >
      • Convair CV-240-580
      • Convair CV-880/990
      • Curtiss C-46
      • Fairchild F-27 / Fokker F27
      • Fairchild-Hiller FH-227
      • SE 210 Caravelle
    • Russian >
      • Ilyushin IL-62
      • Ilyushin IL-86/IL-96
      • Tupolev TU-154B-2/M
  • Real As It Gets
    • Real As It Gets - 1/200
    • Real As It Gets - Africa
    • Real As It Gets - Asia
    • Real As It Gets - China
    • Real As It Gets - Europe
    • Real As It Gets - Middle East
    • Real As It Gets - N America
    • Real As It Gets - Oceania
    • Real As It Gets - Russia
    • Real As It Gets - S America
  • Links